Book Quote:

“Love? He was bewildered. Something which had begun in a half-hearted way, something he had dared himself to do, had turned him inside out and he had no experience, no knowledge, no emotional resources to draw on for help. He felt churned up, with anxiety, confusion, regret even at having started this in the first place.”

Book Review:

Review by Eleanor Bukowsky (OCT 29, 2009)

In The Vows of Silence, the fourth Simon Serrailler mystery, Susan Hill picks up where she left off in The Risk of Darkness. Detective Chief Superintendent Serrailler remains a loner who relishes his job and enjoys his passion for drawing. His warm and compassionate sister, Dr. Cat Deerbon, her husband, Chris, and their three small children return from their nine-month stay in Australia, and Simon resumes his old habit of dropping by to hang out with Cat and her family. However, there are changes in store for the residents of the cathedral town of Lafferton, and not all of them are pleasant.

Hill has never shied away from depicting life’s tragedies. Characters whom we have come to care about experience misfortune and heartbreak, and the author makes no attempt to sugarcoat their grief. The whodunit involves an expert marksman who shoots young women and then disappears, leaving behind no forensic evidence. As the number of victims rises, Simon and his team pull out all the stops to catch the predator. However, without witnesses or any helpful leads, the detectives are frustrated by their inability to apprehend the killer.

The strength of this book lies in its lucid prose style, beautiful descriptive writing, smooth dialogue, and superb characterizations. There are touching scenes between a fifty-two year old man and a forty-six year old woman who are dating for the first time after losing their spouses. Hill sensitively captures their reluctance to take a risk with someone new, lest they experience further heartbreak. The author suggests that all change brings with it an element of uncertainty. When someone takes on a new job, establishes a new relationship, or moves to a new location, there is always the possibility of disappointment. However, if we remain mired in our comfortable and familiar routines out of fear, we may miss out on wonderful experiences and satisfying relationships.

Even for a Serrailler novel, The Vows of Silence has an overabundance of gloom and only a tiny glimmer of light to counterbalance it. It is unlikely that so many catastrophes would happen to so many people in so short a time. Still, Susan Hill draws us in and keeps us in thrall, as we eagerly wait to learn what will happen next.

AMAZON READER RATING: stars-4-0from 4 readers
PUBLISHER: Overlook Hardcover (October 29, 2009)
REVIEWER: Eleanor Bukowsky
AMAZON PAGE: The Vows of Silence
EXTRAS: Excerpt
MORE ON MOSTLYFICTION: Read our review of:

The Risk of Darkness

The Shadows in the Street

If you like this author, try these:

Karin Fossom

Tom Rob Smith

Elena Forbes

Partial Bibliography:

Simon Serrailler Mystery Series:


October 29, 2009 В· Judi Clark В· No Comments
Tags: , , ,  В· Posted in: Sleuths Series, United Kingdom, y Award Winning Author

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.